Homemade Uncrustables (Perfect for the Freezer)

Sharing is caring!

Save time and money at the grocery store by making your own Homemade Uncrustables! Perfect for school lunches, road trips, and picnics, these crustless peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are the perfect solution for when the kids need a satisfying and portable snack.

Three Uncrustables stacked with jam filling oozing out.

Want to save this recipe?

Enter your email & I’ll send it to your inbox. Plus, get great new recipes from me every week!

Making your own Uncrustables gives you full control over the ingredients you feed the kiddos and lets you customize the filling to match your family’s preferences and dietary requirements. That’s why making your own Uncrustables is a way healthier and more nutritious option than store-bought ones.

With only three simple ingredients, these sandwiches come together fast, meaning you can make a large batch and freeze them in no time! Take comfort in knowing you’ll always have healthy and easy lunches on hand!

This post may contain affiliate links, see my disclosure policy for details.

What Are Uncrustables?

Uncrustables are frozen, crustless, sandwiches filled with peanut butter and either grape or strawberry jam.

The appeal of these sandwiches is that they are perfect for kids. The sandwiches are sealed shut, keeping all the peanut butter and jelly neatly inside. And these sandwiches thaw really quickly. You can pack them in a lunch box frozen, and they’ll be thawed and ready to eat by lunch time.

For this homemade Uncrustables recipe, we use healthy whole wheat bread, creamy peanut butter, and a dollop of jam. Using a sandwich sealer, we can recreate a healthier (and less expensive) homemade version that is even better than the ones found at grocery stores.

How To Make DIY Uncrustables

Full ingredient amounts can be found on the recipe card at the bottom of the post.

Equipment You’ll Need

Sandwich sealer– I love this one. It comes with varying sizes of round sandwich cutters and an insert that seals the edges of the bread. It works perfectly every time!

Freezer bags- For freezing and storing your sealed Uncrustables.

Ingredients

Sliced whole wheat bread or white bread: Choose a soft, sliced sandwich bread. Avoid bread with lots of big holes or crusty breads.

Peanut butter: Choose your favorite kind! Regular peanut butter or natural, creamy or crunchy. Use the flavor your family loves most!

Jam or jelly: Use your favorite flavor, store-bought or homemade! If you’re looking for a homemade recipe, try my no pectin mixed berry jam!

Instructions

Remove two pieces of bread and lay them on a cutting board, or cut safe surface.

Two bread circles on a cutting board with a butter knife.

Grab the sandwich cutter portion of your Uncrustable maker ( I use the 3.5″ large cutter), and cut a hole in the center of each slice of bread.

Peanut butter spread on a bread circle.

To make one Uncrustable, you’ll need a tablespoon of peanut butter divided between the two pieces of bread.

Spread a thin layer of peanut butter in the center of the bread cut out, leaving about 1/2″ of the edge clean for sealing.

Jam spread with a butterknife onto a bread circle.

Next, place a dollop of jam or jelly in the center of one of the bread circles, spreading it slightly, but still leaving a 1/2″ of edge clean.

Two bread circles stacked on top of each other.

Take the second piece of bread, and place it peanut butter side down on top of the jelly.

The sandwich cutter around the bread.

Place the sandwich cutter back around your bread circles, and grab the sandwich press insert.

Blue sandwich sealer is on top of the bread.

Press down to seal the edges of the bread.

Once sealed, remove your sandwich from the sandwich cutter.

Repeat these steps to make as many Uncrustables as you need.

Up close photo of homemade Uncrustables on a white plate.

Variations and Substitutions

The best thing about making your own Uncrustables at home is the ability to customize the fillings to suit your family’s needs. Here are some suggestions to make THE BEST crustless little sandwiches that everyone can enjoy!

  • Swap the peanut butter for sun butter or seed butter. This is great when packing lunch boxes for a nut free school.
  • Make Nutella Uncrustables by adding a tablespoon of Nutella to the filling.
  • For those with peanut allergies, use almond butter or cashew butter instead.
  • Use honey in place of jam.
  • Use soft gluten-free bread.

Pro Tips

  1. Use soft sandwich bread. The softer the bread, the easier it is for the edges to seal. Avoid crusty breads like sourdough.
  2. Don’t add too much jelly to the filling. By adding too much filling, the jelly or jam will spill out which will keep the sandwiches from sealing properly and will also make a mess.
  3. Don’t spread the filling all the way out to the edges of the bread circles. You want to leave about 1/2″ of clean edge for easy sealing.

Freezing and Storage

You can freeze your own homemade Uncrustables to have easy healthy lunches on demand at all times!

To freeze, take your prepared Uncrustables and place them on a baking sheet, uncovered. Freeze until solid (2-3 hours).

Once frozen, individually wrap each sandwich really well in plastic wrap. Store the wrapped sandwiches in a freezer bag or container in the freezer for up to a month.

Thawing Homemade Uncrustables

To thaw, remove the quantity of Uncrustables needed and let them sit at room temperature (wrapped in plastic) until thawed.

If you’re packing lunch for school, place a frozen sandwich in your child’s lunch box in the morning, and by afternoon, the sandwich will be completely thawed.

Any thawed Uncrustables that are not being eaten immediately should be stored in the fridge, wrapped in plastic or in an airtight container for up to 3 days.

Toasting

Toasted Uncrustables are SO DELICIOUS. You have a super toasty and warm exterior, with a soft and gooey PB&J center.

To toast Uncrustables in the air fryer: Place a frozen Uncrustable in a cold air fryer and toast at 350F for 5-6 minutes until browned. The outside will be toasty and the center will be cool, but thawed.

For thawed Uncrustables in the air fryer: reduce the toasting time to 4-5 minutes, the process is the same.

To toast in the toaster oven: heat frozen or thawed Uncrustables on the lowest “toast” setting until the outside is toasted and the center feels soft and thawed.

Allow sandwiches to cool before eating!

Homemade Uncrustables on a white platter with peanut butter and jam.

FAQs

Are DIY Uncrustables healthy?

Yes! By making your own Uncrustables at home, you can control the quality of the ingredients and what exactly goes into each sandwich. You can make your own whole wheat bread, and jam, and use a natural peanut butter to make these extra nutritious and delicious for the kids!

What do you do with the edges of the bread?

Leftover crusts can be turned into bread crumbs or homemade croutons. You can also stick a piece of crust in your brown sugar to keep it soft!

Is it cheaper to make Uncrustables at home?

Yes. Using basic peanut butter, jam, and whole wheat bread, a homemade Uncrustable will cost you about $.53 each, vs store-bought (from a 10 pack) which runs about $.94 each. Of course, this is subject to change depending on the ingredients you use and does not include the cost of the sandwich sealer.

Can you freeze homemade Uncrustables?

Yes! See above for freezing and thawing instructions.

Image of a whisk

Click to subscribe to the Barefoot In the Pines newsletter for free recipes each week delivered right to your inbox!

More Kid-Friendly Recipes

Three Uncrustables stacked with jam filling oozing out.

Homemade Uncrustables (Freezer Friendly)

Yield: 1 homemade Uncrustable
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 5 minutes

DIY Uncrustables are easy to make at home and perfect for kids! Make a large batch and freeze your own Uncrustables for a healthy, easy lunch idea, while saving time and money at the grocery store.

Ingredients

  • 2 slices of soft sandwich bread
  • 1 tablespoon of peanut butter, divided
  • 2 teaspoons of jam

Instructions

  1. Using the sandwich cutter of your Uncrustables maker, cut a hole in the center of each slice of bread.*
  2. Spread a thin layer of peanut butter on each bread circle, leaving about 1/2" of the edge clean.
  3. Spoon the jam into the center of one of the bread circles. Spread lightly, still keeping 1/2" of bread clean around the edge.
  4. Grab the second bread circle and place it peanut butter side down onto the jam.
  5. Place the sandwich cutter back around your bread circles. Grab the sandwich sealer piece and press down on the sandwich per the sealer's instructions. Remove the sandwich from the sandwich cutter and inspect the edges to make sure they're sealed.
  6. Serve immediately or freeze for later use.

Notes

*I use the 3.5" large sandwich cutter and sealer for this recipe. You may need to adjust the filling if you use a different size sealer.

To freeze: place your prepared Uncrustables on a baking sheet to freeze solid, about 2-3 hours. Once solid, wrap tightly in plastic wrap and then transfer to a freezer bag or freezer safe container. Store in the freezer for up to a month. Thaw at room temperature wrapped in plastic, or inside of a lunch box.

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 1 Serving Size: 1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 286Total Fat: 10gSaturated Fat: 2gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 6gCholesterol: 0mgSodium: 375mgCarbohydrates: 41gFiber: 3gSugar: 11gProtein: 10g

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *